Download E-books Ought Implies Kant: A Reply to the Consequentialist Critique PDF

By Joel Marks

Ought Implies Kant bargains an unique security of the moral idea of Immanuel Kant, and develops an extension of that theory's account of ethical accountability to incorporate direct tasks to nonhuman animals. The dialogue facilities on a serious exam of consequentialism, the view that the rightness or wrongness of an motion is set exclusively through its effects. Kantianism, in contrast, claims that the center of ethics is to regard all persons―or, in Joel Marks's view, all residing beings―as ends-in-themselves. The consequentialist criterion would appear to allow, certainly require, violating the glory of folks (not to say the glory of alternative animals) if this may bring about a greater consequence. This quantity treats the consequentialist problem to Kantian ethics in numerous novel methods. first of all, the utilitarian model of consequentialism is delineated and defended through a conceptual equipment dubbed by way of the writer because the Consequentialist Continuum. Marks then offers an exhaustive and definitive exposition of the fairly ignored Epistemic Objection to utilitarianism. whereas acknowledging the intuitive attraction of utilitarianism's center conviction―that we must always do what's for the best―Marks argues that this is often an very unlikely injunction to meet, or perhaps to try to satisfy, simply because all the correct result of our activities can by no means be recognized. Kantianism is then brought as a plausible replacement account of our moral tasks. Marks argues that Kantianism is easily in the scope of standard human competence and conforms both good to our moral intuitions as soon as the theory's right interpretation is liked. besides the fact that, Kant's personal model has to be prolonged to house the rightful ethical attention we owe to nonhuman animals. ultimately, Marks employs the inspiration of a Consequentialist phantasm to provide an explanation for utilitarianism's carry on our ethical intuitions, whereas constructing a kind of Consequentialist Kantianism to handle them.
An unique and penetrating exam of a principal debate

Show description

Read or Download Ought Implies Kant: A Reply to the Consequentialist Critique PDF

Similar Criticism books

The Philosophers: Introducing Great Western Thinkers

What higher advent to the realm of philosophy than throughout the lives of its such a lot admired electorate. within the Philosophers, we're brought to 28 of the best thinkers in Western civilization, starting from Aristotle and Plato to Wittgenstein, Heidegger, and Sartre. An illustrious group of students takes us on a concise and illuminating travel of a few of the main impressive minds and enduring principles in historical past.

On Creaturely Life: Rilke, Benjamin, Sebald

In his Duino Elegies, Rainer Maria Rilke means that animals take pleasure in direct entry to a realm of being—the open—concealed from people by means of the workings of recognition and self-consciousness. In his personal analyzing of Rilke, Martin Heidegger reclaims the open because the right area of human life yet means that human lifestyles continues to be haunted by way of vestiges of an animal-like relation to its atmosphere.

Critique and Disclosure: Critical Theory between Past and Future (Studies in Contemporary German Social Thought)

In Critique and Disclosure, Nikolas Kompridis argues provocatively for a richer and extra time-responsive serious conception. He demands a shift within the normative and significant emphasis of severe thought from the slim situation with ideas and methods of Jürgen Habermas's version to a change-enabling disclosure of hazard and the expansion of that means.

African Zion: The Sacred Art of Ethiopia

Ethiopian paintings is a few of the main awesome and least famous of the African continent, and this e-book is the 1st accomplished advent to it to be had in any language. it's the catalogue to an exhibition that would journey the U.S. from October 1993 to January 1996, and in it, a gaggle of prime American, British and Ethiopian students in Ethiopian artwork and tradition introduce and speak about a desirable number of paintings.

Additional info for Ought Implies Kant: A Reply to the Consequentialist Critique

Show sample text content

Rated 4.54 of 5 – based on 15 votes